In School's Ruins, a Town
Confronts the Unthinkable By C. J. CHIVERS
Published: September 6, 2004
Women mourned Sunday at the funeral of Erik Varziyev, 12, w
ho was one of the
more than 300 hostages killed in the Beslan school siege.
The entrance of one classroom at the school, pockmarked by bullets.
ESLAN, Russia, Sept. 5 - Shafts of light passed through bullet holes in
the pupils' desks, which were stacked together at windows, makeshift barricades
against attack. Ghastly sights waited behind them, but almost no one could stay
away.
Middle School No. 1 was opened Sunday to the people of Beslan, who found
themselves drawn toward it by an almost gravitational pull.
After the authorities and the Russian Army slipped away in the darkness on
Saturday night, the school had stood looming and empty, a large and foreboding
shell in which hundreds of hostages had died. As word spread that its security
cordon had vanished, it seemed as if the entire population of the town appeared
to wander its corridors.
The Russian authorities announced Sunday that the death count from the
hostage siege had reached 338, and many of the wounded remained in critical
condition. They also noted that the minister of the interior of North Ossetia,
the republic where Beslan is, had submitted a letter of resignation, but that it
had been refused.
Such news held little attention. The people of Beslan were drawn irresistibly
forward, into the hellish place, to see for themselves. For this small and
impoverished republic, Middle School No. 1 was ground zero.
Its sights were unsparingly grim. The explosions of the two bombs in the
midst of the children, and the final battle that had rolled through the hallways
and classroom on Friday afternoon, had left trails of destruction and carnage,
which combined to form a gruesome display.
The roof of the gymnasium was gone, and the wooden floor of the basketball
court was covered with its wreckage: a thick coat of black ash. Women's and
children's shoes were in places still arranged in lines along the floor.
The bathroom, to one side, showed where the wounded had staggered, leaving
bloody handprints on tiles.
Even the architecture itself suggested that some of the smallest children had
met horrible ends. There was only one door in the gymnasium leading outside.
After the first bomb detonated, many students had survived by pulling themselves
out eight large windows whose glass had been blown away - a providential effect
that offered lanes of escape.
The windows were high, at chest level for an adult, beyond the reach of the
very young.
People stood in the roofless room on Sunday, beside growing stacks of
flowers, with eyes red and raw.
Inside the schoolhouse, with its cracked water pipes and crumbling ceilings,
ferocity's marks appeared at most every turn. Uncountable thousands of bullet
holes and shrapnel-marks scarred the walls. Blood-soaked bandages littered the
floor.
The flesh and hair and bits of bone of suicide bombers were splattered along
the ceilings and walls of a classroom on the first floor. The remains of another
suicide bomber coated the corridor near the cafeteria. Many townspeople picked
their way through the stinking mess with their shirts pulled over their noses.
Incongruity was the norm. New badminton rackets were bundled together among
the dust and debris, as were an assortment of brightly colored jump ropes.
In the second-story assembly hall, in a corner of the building where the
militants had held out almost into Friday night, the floor was ruined by seven
shrapnel-pocked craters that marked the explosions of grenades, presumably
thrown into the hall as Russian soldiers cleared the last pockets of resistance,
room by room.
On the auditorium's stage, a large cut-out display read "Happy Holiday."
On the wall of a classroom opposite a suicide bomber's grisly remains, there
were signs for arithmetic class.
"4+2 = 6," read one. "6-2 = 4."
A strip of the bomber's scalp was curled on a nearby desk.
In one hallway, a man stopped and scraped his shoe along a broken board. He
had stepped in something sticky by the door. "Brains," he said.
No matter how repugnant a place Middle School No. 1 had become, the people
could not turn away. They wandered by the hundreds, leading each other from
place to place.
Some sifted through the rubble and pulled out hints of the terrorists'
preparations: abandoned gas masks, compasses, bags of dried soups and first aid
gear. They clustered over two large holes where someone had pulled up the
library's wooden floor, spaces in which the authorities said they believed that
ammunition and equipment had been cached in advance of the attack.
Residents also spoke of the roles that had been forced upon them, survivors
and rescuers walking among the widowers and parents who had lost daughters and
sons.
One boy, Murat Kulayev, 13, had used a teapot to douse the last fire, the
smoldering and charred floor of a classroom at the end of the corridor on the
second floor. He had been one of the fortunate few to escape the terrorists'
initial attack.
He retraced his route, narrating. As the masked men herded the student body
and staff through a door, he said, leading them toward their eventual
confinement on the basketball court, he and a friend spotted a chance for
escape.
Passing by a stairway just inside the entrance, they broke left and bounded
upstairs, chased by two men with beards that hung beneath their masks.
Lithe and young, the youths outdistanced their pursuers, who were laden with
ammunition and with rifles slung across their backs. The chase passed madly down
the empty hallway, with each glimpse back by the boys providing the sight of two
terrorists not far behind.
At last Murat and his friend reached the school's opposite side, where they
broke a window on the stairwell, climbed outside and reached the ground by
swiftly shinnying down a pipe. "Then we ran away," he said.
By that time, their classmates were being massed in the gym, where many would
die. At least 191 people are still missing from among them, according to a list
the families compiled, and their absence drove people here to hysteria.
One woman in a blue-print dress and head scarf wandered the first-floor
hallways, wailing, screaming, searching the place on her own. The townspeople
who watched her pass, weeping as well, said she was looking for a son who had
not come home.
She entered the nearly empty cafeteria and passed through it, and proceeded
even to the kitchen and pantries, to the last unlit and darkened corner,
screaming and sobbing, pulling herself up over the rubble to look for him behind
a refrigerator that had been knocked on its side. She found nothing, and
wandered out, filling the room with piercing, incomprehensible cries.
Upstairs, Oleg Kasumov picked through the ruins of a second-floor classroom.
He lifted a drying bouquet of red roses, brought for the first day of school,
and tossed them aside. "They never were used as they were intended," he said.
Mr. Kasumov was gathering books scattered along the floor and stacking them
onto a stretcher to carry them away. It was the office of his sister, Yelena
Ganiyeva, the school's chief of staff.
His sister had survived, but was hospitalized. He said she was a book
collector and would want her collection back. The task seemed to sustain Mr.
Kasumov, who worked steadily at stacking the books neatly, distracting him from
the fact that his daughter, Inna, had not yet been found.
Down the hall, Teimuraz Kanukov stood in a foul-smelling classroom with his
three teenage daughters and two younger sons. A windowsill was streaked by large
dried pools of blood, the platform from which residents said the terrorists had
shoved out dead hostages.
The window overlooked a lawn. Mr. Kanukov had rushed the wounded and dead
from the school's grounds during the battle, risking his life along the edges of
the lawn to carry them to waiting cars. He pointed out the wall outside where he
had taken cover, just under the school's windows, and described a scene of human
nature turned upside down: a woman shooting a man who was trying to save his
children.
"So many bullets were flying that you could not even put your nose past
here," he said, but one father could not control himself and ran across the
grass to try to reach the school. He made it about 100 feet, was struck and fell
down.
Then, as they watched him writhing and exposed, one of the women among the
terrorists appeared above him.
"She was shooting from the window, finishing him," Mr. Kanukov said. "We saw
how the bullets hit his body."
On a table down the hallway the twisted fins of a rocket-propelled grenade
stood on a table beside a stack of books.
On top was one of the novels by Nikolai Gogol, from the 19th century,
Russia's golden age of prose. The title, facing upward, was "Dead Souls."
Editor: Frankspeak |