Insurgents Seize Russian
School; Scores Hostage By C. J. CHIVERS and STEVEN LEE MYERS
Published: September 2, 2004
ESLAN, Russia, Thursday, Sept. 2 - Heavily armed insurgents, some with
explosives strapped to their bodies, seized a school here in southern Russia on
Wednesday, he
rded scores of schoolchildren, parents and teachers into its
gymnasium and threatened to kill them.
Russian soldiers rescued an unidentified child on
Wednesday from a school that was seized by heavily armed insurgents in North
Ossetia.
Ossetian women waited yesterday for news about the
hostages - an estimated 120 to 300 children, parents and teachers - seized in a
school in Beslan. Below, some of the troops who surrounded the school.
Russian soldiers rescued an unidentified child yesterday
from a school that was seized by heavily armed insurgents in North
Ossetia.
Several people died in the initial rebel raid on the
school in Beslan
More than a dozen guerillas, including men and women, stormed Middle School
No. 1 in this town in North Ossetia, not far from Chechnya on Russia's southern
border with Georgia, as children lined up outside the building just moments
after the opening of the school year. Estimates of the number of hostages ranged
from 120 to more than 300.
Gunfire erupted during the seizure and afterward before quieting by Wednesday
evening. Four to seven people are believed to have been killed in the initial
raid, Lev Dzugayev, a spokesman for North Ossetia's president, said here. Two
police officers guarding the school are missing. At least a dozen others were
reported wounded, some gravely.
The local police, as well as special forces and soldiers from Russia's 58th
Army, surrounded the school, creating a nervous standoff that continued into
Thursday in stormy weather that flooded the streets.
Officials at the scene would not discuss who they thought the insurgents
were, but a man who answered the phone at the school shortly after the siege
began and identified himself as a spokesman for the attackers said they were
Chechens.
The number of hostages remained unclear, reflecting a scene of confusion and
anxiety as hundreds of relatives gathered outside in fearful vigil, sometimes
having to be restrained from trying to approach the school. Rosa Tsurayeva
rushed to the school when she heard gunfire, but by the time she arrived, her
son, Zaur, 14, and daughter, Alina, 10, were among the hostages.
"I have to get there," she said she had told the officers who stopped her.
"My children are there." She broke into sobs, rocking in a chair at a social
center that has turned into a shelter for waiting relatives. "They would not let
me."
The man who identified himself on the phone as the guerrillas' spokesman said
they wanted talks with the leaders of North Ossetia and neighboring Ingushetia,
as well as with a pediatrician who took part in negotiations with insurgents who
seized a Moscow theater in October 2002.
"Wipe your sniffles," the man said, speaking crudely in accented Russian,
when asked what they hoped to discuss with the officials. He then hung up.
The siege began the morning after a suicide bomber set off an explosion
outside a subway station in Moscow, killing herself and at least 10 others in
the latest convulsion of terrorist violence that has struck fear into Russians.
Because of the nature of the explosives used, officials said on Wednesday, that
attack appeared linked to the bombings of two passenger airliners, which crashed
simultaneously on Aug. 24, killing 90.
Russia's defense minister, Sergei B. Ivanov, speaking in Moscow as the
hostage crisis unfolded in the south, said the attacks amounted to war.
"War has been declared on us, where the enemy is unseen, and there is no
front," Mr. Ivanov said. "This is regrettably not the first, and I fear not the
last, terrorist act."
President Vladimir V. Putin, for the second time in eight days, disrupted his
working vacation in the Black Sea resort of Sochi and returned to Moscow. He did
not immediately discuss the hostage crisis, but in an interview with Turkish
journalists on the eve of a state visit to Turkey, Mr. Putin said Russia would
never negotiate with terrorists or Chechen separatists, who have now been
fighting Russian forces, with only a brief halt, since 1994.
"We shall fight against them, throw them in prisons and destroy them," Mr.
Putin said in remarks reported by Interfax.
But officials began talks with the guerrillas at the school in North Ossetia
on Wednesday in hopes of ending the siege peacefully.
With the building in their control and evidently wired with mines and
explosives, the guerrillas sent two notes, one with a hostage, and a
videocassette, the officials said. The videocassette was blank, the officials
said. One of the notes included a mobile telephone number, the other the simple
message, "Wait," a spokesman here, Oleg Sogalov, said in a telephone interview.
The man who answered the school's phone said he represented the Second Group
of Salakhin Riadus Shakhidi, a rebel contingent believed to be headed by
Chechnya's most notorious insurgent commander, Shamil Basayev. Russian officials
maintained that it was premature to say who had seized the school.
Mr. Basayev has previously been involved in or claimed responsibility for
some of the worst attacks in Russia stemming from the long conflict in Chechnya.
They include a raid in 1995 into Budennovsk, a town near Chechnya in the
Stavropol region, during the first Chechen war. In that attack, his fighters
killed 147 people and then held more than 1,000 people hostage in a hospital.
That raid ended when the captors loaded hundreds of hostages on buses and
drove to Chechnya. Mr. Basayev also claimed responsibility for rebel attacks in
Ingushetia in June that left nearly 100 dead.
Officials said negotiators had established contact with the guerrillas in the
school. The director of the local branch of the Federal Security Service, Valery
Andreyev, said in televised remarks that the guerrillas had refused to allow
food and water to be sent in for the hostages.
Mr. Putin's adviser on Chechen affairs, Alsanbek Aslakhanov, told Interfax
that the guerrillas had demanded a withdrawal of Russian troops from Chechnya
and the release of insurgents jailed after the raids in Ingushetia in June.
The guerrillas threatened to destroy the school if any attempt was made to
free the hostages and vowed to kill 50 schoolchildren for each guerrilla killed,
North Ossetia's interior minister, Kazbek Dzantiyev, said, according to Russian
news agencies. Middle School No. 1 has more than 800 students, ages 6 to 16, and
some 60 teachers. Several officials said there appeared to be 15 to 20
guerrillas, at least two of them women. Wearing camouflage and masks and heavily
armed with grenades and explosives, they apparently stormed the school using a
hijacked police car and a truck, the officials said.
The raid occurred only moments after an opening-day ceremony attended by
students, their parents and teachers. The first day of school here, known as Day
of Knowledge, is one of the most festive days for Russian families, with
children and parents dressing up and carrying flowers to greet teachers.
A few students managed to escape, apparently after hiding in a boiler
room.The state television network, Rossiya, showed a camouflaged soldier racing
a young girl to safety, followed by an elderly woman.
"I was standing near the gates," one student, Zarubek Tsumartov, said on
Rossiya. "Music was playing. When I saw three people running with guns, I
thought it was a joke at first. Then they fired in the air. And we ran away."
The siege in Beslan had portentous echoes of one of the most notorious
terrorist acts in recent Russian history: the hostage crisis at a Moscow theater
in October 2002. A band of insurgents seized the theater during a musical,
"Nord-Ost," and held more than 700 hostages for 57 hours before commandoes
stormed the building. At least 41 rebels died in the raid, but so did at least
129 hostages, most from the effects of a nerve gas pumped into the theater.
Russia's second war in Chechnya began in 1999 and shows few signs of ending,
even though Russian soldiers and security officers control most of the
mountainous republic.
The raid in Ingushetia in June, and a similar one in Chechnya's capital,
Grozny, on Aug. 21 that killed as many as 50, demonstrated the rebels' capacity
to stage larger operations, if intermittently. The school siege - as well as the
attacks against two airliners last week and outside a Moscow subway station on
Tuesday night - bracketed the presidential election in Chechnya held last Sunday
to replace Akhmad Kadyrov, a former rebel turned Kremlin supporters who was
assassinated in Grozny in May.
Chechnya's separatist leader, Aslan Maskhadov, who served as president during
the de facto independence from 1996 to 1999 before fleeing Grozny in the second
war, denied involvement in the terrorist attacks and in Wednesday's siege.
Across North Ossetia, schools closed, as did the region's airport. The
authorities announced they had closed the region's heavily guarded borders with
Ingushetia, Kabardino-Balkaria and Stavropol, and with Georgia.
Russia's military campaign in Chechnya, now in its sixth year, has faced
international criticism because its forces have been accused of unwarranted
killings and other abuses in their pursuit of separatist rebels. But in the
aftermath of the last week's attacks, political leaders from the United States
and European and other countries expressed common cause with Russia.
President Bush called Mr. Putin and offered support. The United Nations
Security Council also scheduled an emergency meeting.
C.J. Chivers reported from Beslan for this article, and Steven Lee Myers
from Moscow. Nikolai Khalip contributed reporting from Moscow.
Editor: Frankspeak |